A true story of China in Africa

Posted by on 23 April 2010

I have recently finished my BA paper and I am now trying to convert it in a publishable academic article. I believe this essay brings significant contributions to both the field of political science and anthropology and also a more nuanced vision on Sino-African relations.

My thesis is the following:China’s engagement in Africa, its extractive and mercantile goals, the impact Chinese state and non-state actors have on local economies, and the implications of China’s increased commitment to African states’ developmental agendas have become major topics of debate in Africa and in the Western world of late. Although much has been written about “China in Africa” in the last decade, little attention has been paid to exactly how Chinese immigrants and Africans interact on the ground. On those rare occasions when scholars do field work before analyzing the impact of the Chinese presence on the continent, various voices and opinions are still left out. Unfortunately, the views often presented in academic work are the ones of the African leaders, bureaucrats and other local experts. As a consequence, we still know very little about how average African people see the Chinese state and non-state actors, and how the two groups of people interact with each other on a daily basis.

In this essay, I argue that the socio-economic relations between Chinese immigrants and local residents in Tanzania are predicated on the same pattern of interaction and cooperation that has governed the political and economic (partial) alliance between the Chinese and the Tanzanian states for the last fifty years. Despite the fact that Chinese immigrants and residents of Dar es Salaam might, at times, have very different agendas and perhaps strikingly different ways of seeing and analyzing this partnership, their on-site cooperation is greatly influenced by their common history, past success stories of mutual cooperation, and future potential benefits of this partnership, be those real, potential or imagined. In addition, while Tanzanians and Chinese also have similar views on how they see their mutually beneficial relations, various aspects of this partnership are constantly being negotiated and renegotiated on the ground – in the market, in the informal sector and even at the state level. Consequently, both formal and informal Sino-Tanzanian relations demonstrate a great deal of both Chinese and Tanzanian agency. This clearly suggests that the story of China in Africa is not the monolithic, hegemonic, and unidirectional relationship that some Western scholars have previously suggested.

By exploring both the Chinese state’s engagement in Tanzania and the Chinese immigrants’ commitment and subsequent consequences of their presence in the country, I also wish to suggest that the impact of the age of China in Africa has been underestimated. I believe this impact is even greater than previously thought precisely because Sino-Tanzanian relations suggest a pattern of continuous interaction between the Chinese and local people that is constantly redefined and renegotiated according to the needs and expectations of each group. This is an adaptive process and, most importantly, it is one that reflects the interests of many Chinese immigrants and local people. In this process, as it may be expected, some locals do not experience these benefits or are negatively affected by the Chinese Diaspora’s economic affairs. However, from the perspective of the average Tanzanian, Chinese presence in the country is welcomed, as it creates more competition and opportunities as well as makes affordable a wide variety of goods. At the same time, the Chinese Diaspora is on the rise, and this essay will analyze some of the factors that can explain the surge in Chinese immigrants in the country and its consequences.Understanding the history of the state and the Asian immigrants in Tanzania, their present albeit yet limited role in Tanzanian economy and the way the Chinese Diaspora is perceived by the locals will provide a new understanding of what China in Africa is, its impact and potential future trends. I analyze the Chinese’s engagement in Tanzania by using a conceptual framework proposed by scholar Stephanie Rupp. She argues that the China-Africa relations are neither neo-colonial nor imperialist but can be better described as post-colonial interdependency. I plan to analyze Mrs. Rupp’s hypothesis by applying it to Sino-Tanzanian relations in the light of the state-to-state patterns of collaboration and the informal interactions between Chinese immigrants and local Tanzanians. The goal of the Chinese state, and that of most Chinese immigrants, in Africa is clear: they are there to stay. Since Mrs. Rupp’s theoretical framework is an accurate assessment of Sino-African relations, I will use the ethnographic data from Tanzania to provide a more comprehensive analysis of what a pattern of interdependency entails in the context of the socio-economic relations between Chinese immigrants and local residents in one particular African country.

What is perhaps the most important thing you will notice is the quintessential difference between my view of the Chinese state and the Chinese immigrants to Africa between the 2007 and 2010, that is before I started doing research on China and Africa and after I centralized my data. You can find my initial, false position on China in Africa here. If this intro to my BA paper has made you interested in reading the whole manuscript you can do it by clicking here.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • email
  • Furl
  • Reddit
  • SphereIt
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • muti
  • Mixx

8 Comments For This Post

  1. Winslowalrob says:

    Great great piece, and congratulations on finishing it up. Your on the ground research was really well-done and I enjoyed reading it!
    .-= Winslowalrob´s last blog ..Sweet Jebus I HATE Firewalls =-.

  2. Winslowalrob says:

    Dang your paper was sweet. Great on the ground research that went beyond anecdotal research.
    .-= Winslowalrob´s last blog ..Sweet Jebus I HATE Firewalls =-.

  3. Winslowalrob says:

    Great work for the paper. I really enjoyed the research!
    .-= Winslowalrob´s last blog ..Sweet Jebus I HATE Firewalls =-.

  4. wei says:

    The thesis you mentioned at the end is such a great piece of work. It contains so many on the ground researches that make it extremely robust and convincable. In your conclusion you mention that China’s surge into Africa has caught African leaders somewhat unprepared. I would say Chinese companies and Chinese people are also unprepared to some extent on how to engage with African local people. The laws in African countries and that of China’s are very different. Many African counties’ labor law are more protective than that of China’s, not to mention in China self-governed worker unions do not exist. So African leadership should strength their legislation and law enforcement on foreign labor activities; while Chinese government bear the responsibility to educate her own people, who are to venture into Africa, to learn and obey the local laws. As the old Chinese saying, “Enter the local, Follow the convention” (Ru Xiang Sui Su). This would eventually prevent unease from escalating on both sides.

  5. Codrin Arsene says:

    @ Wei
    I agree with much of you say. Yet I kindly remind you that I’m actually dealing with Chinese workers who are involved in the informal sector and who have little or absolutely no connection to the Chinese state. In addition, while I agree that Chinese companies have been pretty slow at learning the local legislation, they have also been really good at adapting to the local conditions. Much more than other foreign companies for example. You points on legislation and law enforcement are well taken.

  6. Alex Chomo says:

    Thaaaank you for this analysis. I hope you will try to publish this piece. There is such a dire need for more ethnographic research like this. Which is really amazing and dead accurate!!!!

  7. Codrin Arsene says:

    Hi guys
    Thank you for your kind words. And for your recommendations.
    Codrin

  8. Christian says:

    Hello Codrin,
    I enjoyed your article. I am the Art Director for a Chinese current affairs magazine named CHINAFRICA. I would like to use this shot in an up coming article on Sino-African relations. Did you take it yourself?.. or could you tell me where you sourced it from?

    Any help will be much appreciated.

    Cheers,
    Christian

1 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Weekend links! | Justice for all says:

    [...] A true story of China in Africa [...]

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge